Serially Lost, Part Three: Friendship

When I was taking Writing 101, there were some assignments that were supposed to be part of a series.  I finished the first two but never did get to write the third one.  The theme for it has been in my head for a while.  Though not exactly fulfilling the original assignment, this third part relates to each of the previous two and ties them together because of lessons I learned in both situations.  They were lessons I learned because of my own selfishness and insensitivity; in each case, I lost a valuable friend.

In the first blog, I wrote about getting a haircut and losing my trust in my sister.  It had happened in a place called Muldavinville, where I spent most of the summers of my childhood.  Muldavinville was an idyllic place for children, a safe environment with plenty of room to explore, play, imagine, and just run around.  Because many of the families came back year after year, during my 10 summers there I had good friends that I looked forward to being with for July and August.  One of my best friends was named Wendy.  She had two teen-aged sisters – much older than we – and a baby sister.  I loved to eat at her house, because her sisters would cut up our meat for us in tiny bites and call us “Lamb Chop.”  It was fun to be there.  It was also fun to run wild together outside.  My memory has so many gaps, but I do remember playing pioneer in a miniature realistic log cabin belonging to a neighbor.  I remember going down to the lake to swim and play in the sand, while our mothers chatted or played Scrabble.  When we children realized it was getting late in the afternoon, we would cover ourselves in mud so that we’d have to go back in the lake one more time to wash off.

Wendy was a year or two younger than I was, but we were on the same wavelength…..until I got to be around 10 or 11.  That was when I started showing the first inclinations toward growing up.  I shouldn’t have been surprised when my two youngest daughters leapt almost overnight from unconcernedly playing with stuffed animals to caring how they looked and dressed; I did the same thing.  The difference was that my daughters made the leap together, while I chose to leave my friend Wendy behind.

I remember the catalyst clearly.  Wendy and I and some other kids were playing a twirling game; two of us would hold hands and twirl around together and then let go.  The problem was that when we let go, Wendy fell and badly broke her arm.  It was horrifying, not just because of what had happened – the arm at an odd angle, Wendy crying. all of us looking on in shock – but because I somehow felt responsible.  My solution, when Wendy came back the next day with her arm in a cast, was to avoid her and to hang out with the older kids.  I didn’t want to play kid games any more. She was hurt and didn’t understand. I remember her father and sisters talking to me about it, but I don’t think it made a difference in my behavior; I had moved on.

In the second blog of the series, I talked about finding my voice in a college class and of a friend who was instrumental in helping me to do so.  This friend, Susan, was very independent.  She lived in her own apartment, had a job and a boyfriend, and was always supportive of me.  One day, however, she sat me down and talked to me about friendship.  She told me that friendship had to go both ways, that friends needed to listen to each other and support each other, and that I had always been so wrapped up in myself and my own issues that I’d never asked her about hers.  I had assumed that because she seemed so together on the outside that all was well on the inside. I had not gone beyond finding my own voice to learning to listen deeply and caringly to another’s. Susan broke off our friendship because she was tired of being the one who poured herself into it while I just received what she gave and didn’t reciprocate.  She moved on.

I am blessed today with many good friends, from all times and places of my journeying through life.  I think I have learned to be a good friend as well, and the hard lessons I learned from my failures with Wendy and Susan have helped me.  Yet I still wish that somehow, some day, I could communicate with each of them again, ask about their lives and families, reminisce about the good times, and finally say to Wendy and to Susan what I have been wanting to say for these many years:  “I am sorry I was not there when you needed me and that I didn’t offer comfort when you were hurting.  I am sorry that I failed you as a friend and let you go out of my life, when you had already enriched it so much.  I am sorry for the years of friendship that we have missed because of my selfishness.  I am really and truly sorry for being such a jerk. Please forgive me.”


7 Comments on “Serially Lost, Part Three: Friendship”

  1. kathdown says:

    Thanks for sharing. I always enjoy reading your posts. Friendships take work to maintain. I am guilty of letting many of mine fall by the wayside because I got busy with other things. Do you think there are times when it is okay to “move on”? Is it always selfish, or do life changes sometimes warrant changes in friendships. Do I have to feel GUILTY???? Sometimes friendships ebb and flow, too. Even ours sort of faded to the background for a while. Glad we are in the flow stage again! Love you! Kathy

    Sent from my iPad

    >

    • mamaemme says:

      Well, I am no relationship guru, but I think some friendships do just fall by the wayside. It’s not just busyness, though that’s part of it, but it often is a lack of the reciprocity I talked about in my post. Sometimes you need to just pour into someone without return, but at other times it may be best for both of you to end that kind of friendship.

      Sometimes you need to let go of unhealthy friendships, and sometimes, as you said, life changes warrant friendship changes.

      I think you will agree that it is true for us as friends that, although the ebb and flow of our lives may have separated us geographically and resulted in less communication between us, we are always able to pick up where we left off. Friends of the heart are friends forever.
      You are a friend of my heart, and I love you, too!

  2. Harry Schneider says:

    I just did a google search to see if memories of Muldavinville exist in cyberspace. Yours seems to be the one and only. We spent a number of summers there… I’m not certain but probably ’62-64 or thereabouts. I was a rather un-athletic geeky boy (9-11 yrs old or so) but whenever I arrived in Muldavinville I lost my self consciousness and inhibitions and was temporarily a star athlete and very popular. As soon as we returned to Whitestone I was back to being a nerd with few friends.

    I remember the walk to the lake, baseball games, a scavenger hunt, another younger kid named Lawrence, a lady named Tracy (maybe?) who my parents whispered had gone bald… Was there a clubhouse of some sort?

    What years were you there? I have a number of scattered memories, I wonder if any of ours intersect? My family was Seymour, Cynthia, Lucy and Harry Schneider.

    • mamaemme says:

      Hi Harry! Always good to hear from a fellow Muldavinville person. I’ve not blogged in ages; I keep meaning to but then get distracted. Going back over previous replies, I found several I’d neglected to approve; some have more info and memories about other Muldavinville families. We (the Greene family) were there from 1952 or 1953 through 1962 or 1963, so we probably were gone before your family came. For many of us, those were the best times of our lives. I, too, felt that it was a place that I could run free and be myself, and I well remember the nature walks, the lake, the baseball and volleyball games, and the casino on the hill, where we’d have spaghetti dinners and the parents sometimes put on entertainments. We had campfires with lots of singing and roasted marshmallows. Did you also take trips into North Branch and Jeffersonville to shop or go to movies? There was a FB group for people who summered in the Catskills, but few on there from Muldavinville, and I’m no longer on FB anyway. I’d be glad to be part of something specific to our experiences. Emily

      • Harry Schneider says:

        Thank you for your response. I think we probably intersected the last summer you were there. At any rate I appreciate rekindling my Muldavinville memories. One question (and then I will leave you alone!) I have no memory of how food happened there. Was there a chef who prepared meals at the canteen? I don’t recall a kitchen or cooking in the cabin. Strange I cannot remember anything about meals…

        Oh, and btw, I absolutely remember the Rexall. It was exciting, happening place!

      • mamaemme says:

        We’re operating on a time difference, as I’m currently living in South Korea with my daughter and her family, hence the delay in responding.
        Each cabin, cottage, or bungalow, as we called them back then, had its own kitchen. My mother prepared meals there, but since she was also on vacation and my father only came up on weekends, staying in NYC to work during the week, I expect she didn’t do too much cooking. No chef or canteen in my time. The casino on the hill was basically a big empty building; I think there was a piano, and probably chairs and tables that were set up when needed. When we had communal dinners, like the annual spaghetti and meatball feast, they were prepared by the families and brought up to the building.
        I don’t remember what I wrote in my original post, but for the first few years that we were there, there were no showers in the cabins, only two communal showers with hot water provided by a coal-burning stove.
        We didn’t use plastic back then, and our trash was all recycled: food to the farmer for his pigs, cans and bottles in appropriate metal trash cans in a central location, paper burnt.
        I remember the Rexall especially because, in addition to the ice cream soda we usually got, my friend Ruth and I would get to purchase paperback books when we went there. We’d row out to the middle of the lake in the morning and sit together, enjoying the feel and smell of the new books while reading.
        With my children, most of our family vacations were at the beach, and we have good memories of fun times there.
        However, my ideal of family vacations is still in the mountains, hunting salamanders in the woods, playing in a lake,
        and running wild in an enclosed community.
        Glad you got in touch, Harry!

  3. Walt Santner says:

    My Dad came home from his military service in Europe, in 1946.

    He’d gone in the year I was born, 1943.

    I celebrated my third birthday there, at the end of July.

    One of my parents life long friends was Archie Toder related to the Muldavins, which was how we came to stay there. Archie went back for many years afterwards.

    We came from Brooklyn for several Summers. I do have many fond memories.

    To a city kid swimming in the lake was a treat! My Dad started a garden and I
    recall young carrots.

    There was a general store down the road. An almost tragedy was averted when my Mom became unwell and went to a nearby hospital. We visited a nearby farm and I remember, cows and goats.


Leave a comment